6. The Body (5×16)
“The Body” is a monumental episode for BtVS.  It deals with Buffy’s mom suddenly dying and how different people react to death.  It’s also the first time that a character has died from natural causes on the show, which Buffy hates because the anger she feels cannot be channelled.  It’s the rare episode where there isn’t a ‘baddie’ until she kills a vampire at the very end of the episode.  The most emotional scene for me was seeing how her friends reacted.  Willow obsesses over a shirt, Xander is angry, and Anya simply cannot comprehend  death and mortality.  The scene comes to an emotional end when Xander puts his fist in a wall.  For  a show like BtVS, which is grandiose with its plotting, seeing the characters do these mundane things gives you a whole new level to connect with them.  Whedon has gone on to say that he wrote this episode to show how mundane death really is.  It’s a very dark notion but if you think about it we never realize it because of our emotions.  If any episode deserved an Emmy, it should’ve been this one.
Most excellent list! Anyanka’s death in The Chosen always got to me too…
Personally, I always had a soft spot for The Zeppo.
Thanks!! I also love The Zeppo, Storyteller, and Superstar. This was a hard list to make for sure.
So glad that Hush is on here – it has always been my favorite – nothing like The Gentleman to make life a little creepier.